Order picking process simulation: four pickers and a consolidation desk
Orders are released every 1.2 minutes to four pickers who take a lognormal Lognormal(4.2, 1.5) minutes, then pass one consolidation desk. Picking runs 88% busy and consolidation 86%. A fifth picker cuts the picking wait from 3.7 min to 40 sec but doubles the wait at consolidation.
The process
2 stations, as in the template: Picking (4 workers, Lognormal(4.2, 1.5) min); Consolidation (1 worker, Triangular(0.6, 0.9, 1.6) min).
Results of the run
| Station | Workers | Busy | Average wait | Longest line (avg of runs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Picking | 4 | 88% | 3.7 min | 18.8 |
| Consolidation | 1 | 86% | 1.4 min | 7.9 |
Highlighted: the busiest station. Throughput 50.1 an hour (95% interval 49.7 to 50.6); time in the process 10.3 min.
Two stations, almost the same load
50.0 order lines are released an hour. Picking has four pickers at Lognormal(4.2, 1.5) minutes each, so it carries 3.50 servers of work: 88% busy, with an average line of 3.1 orders. The single consolidation desk takes Triangular(0.6, 0.9, 1.6) minutes and is 86% busy. Neither has much room, and the long right tail of picking times (lognormal, sd 1.5) is what makes picking the one with the longer line.
A fifth picker moves the wait downstream
With five pickers the picking wait falls from 3.7 min to 40 sec and picker utilization to 70%. The consolidation desk, unchanged, sees its average wait rise from 1.4 min to 2.9 min and its longest line from 7.9 to 15.6 orders. Faster picking delivers orders to the desk in tighter bunches, and a desk that is already 86% busy absorbs them badly. Net effect: an order spends 8.8 min in the process instead of 10.3 min, an improvement of 1.6 min, but the better next step is the desk, not another picker.
To size pickers from your own order rate and pick time, use the picker staffing calculator; it handles one stage. This template is for what happens across stages.
The what-if
| Run | Units per hour | Time in the process (95% interval) | Busiest station |
|---|---|---|---|
| As in the template | 50.1 | 10.3 min (9.8 min to 10.8 min) | Picking, 88% busy |
| A fifth picker | 50.1 | 8.8 min (8.5 min to 9 min) | Consolidation, 86% busy |
The what-if adds one picker. The consolidation desk is unchanged, which is the point of the comparison.
Run it yourself
This template has 2 stations and fits the Free plan, which simulates up to 5. Opening it needs a free account so your copy can be saved. Change any number to match your site and press play. The inputs on this page are illustrative, so treat the results as a demonstration of behaviour and not as a forecast.
Open this exact case in SimflowlySee all templates
Questions
How many pickers does this template need?
Four pickers carry 3.5 servers of work at 50.0 lines an hour, so 88% busy. That leaves little room: the picking wait is 3.7 min. A fifth picker takes it to 70% busy and 40 sec, which is why staffing near 100% fails.
Why did the wait at consolidation get worse with a fifth picker?
Picking smooths the flow when it is busy. With a fifth picker, orders finish sooner and reach the single desk in bunches, so its wait goes from 1.4 min to 2.9 min. Problems often move to the next station, which is why a map of the whole process matters more than one calculator.
Are these pick times benchmarks?
No. The 4.2-minute mean and the long tail are illustrative inputs chosen to show the behaviour. Time your own pickers, enter the mean and the spread, and rerun. The result is only as good as those measurements; the Pro plan can fit distributions from an Excel or CSV time study.