Cross-docking simulation: receiving doors, staging and outbound doors
In this cross-dock a truck arrives every 15 minutes and holds a receiving door for Triangular(20, 30, 50) minutes. Two receiving doors carry 2.22 doors of work and the two outbound doors 2.11: both are overloaded. Adding a third receiving door cuts the receiving wait from 7.1 h to 12 min, and the line moves to the outbound doors.
The process
4 stations, as in the template: Receiving doors (2 workers, Triangular(20, 30, 50) min); Sort to lanes (3 workers, Normal(25, 6) min); Stage for outbound (2 workers, Triangular(10, 15, 25) min); Outbound doors (2 workers, Triangular(20, 30, 45) min).
Results of the run
| Station | Workers | Busy | Average wait | Longest line (avg of runs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Receiving doors | 2 | 99% | 7.1 h | 55.4 |
| Sort to lanes | 3 | 50% | 0 sec | 1.0 |
| Stage for outbound | 2 | 50% | 7 sec | 1.1 |
| Outbound doors | 2 | 94% | 11.5 min | 3.7 |
Highlighted: the busiest station. Throughput 3.6 an hour (95% interval 3.5 to 3.6); time in the process 8.9 h.
An overloaded door is not a steady wait
Trucks arrive at random every 15 minutes on average, 4 an hour. Receiving takes Triangular(20, 30, 50) minutes, a mean of 33.3, so the two receiving doors carry 2.22 doors of work: 111% loaded. A system loaded over 100% has no steady average: the line grows for as long as you run it. Over 5 simulated days the receiving wait is 7.1 h on average and the line reaches 55.4 trucks, and both numbers would be larger over a longer run. Throughput is 3.6 trucks an hour, below the 4 arriving, because trucks are still waiting at the end.
Fix one end and the other shows
Adding a third receiving door brings that wait to 12 min and receiving to 74% busy. Throughput rises to 3.7 an hour, but the trucks now reach the outbound doors faster than they can leave: outbound carries 2.11 doors of work on 2 doors, 106% loaded, and its wait grows from 11.5 min to 4.5 h. Sorting and staging, at about 50% busy, are not the problem in either run. A cross-dock is only as fast as its slowest door, and here both ends need work.
To size one set of doors for your own peak and dwell, use the dock door calculator. To size a yard in front of them, use the limited waiting room calculator.
The what-if
| Run | Units per hour | Time in the process (95% interval) | Busiest station |
|---|---|---|---|
| As in the template | 3.6 | 8.9 h (7.9 h to 9.9 h) | Receiving doors, 99% busy |
| A third receiving door | 3.7 | 6.5 h (5.6 h to 7.4 h) | Outbound doors, 98% busy |
The what-if adds a third receiving door and leaves everything else as is, over the same 5 days.
Run it yourself
This template has 4 stations and fits the Free plan, which simulates up to 5. Opening it needs a free account so your copy can be saved. Change any number to match your site and press play. The inputs on this page are illustrative, so treat the results as a demonstration of behaviour and not as a forecast.
Open this exact case in SimflowlySee all templates
Questions
Why is there no steady average wait at the receiving doors?
Two doors carry 2.22 doors of work, more than they have, so trucks arrive faster than they leave and the line keeps growing. A wait of 7.1 h is only the average over 5 days; a longer run gives a larger number. The first fix is capacity, not a better average.
What does a third receiving door change?
Receiving drops to 74% busy and its wait to 12 min. Trucks then flow faster to the outbound doors, which were already 106% loaded, so their wait rises to 4.5 h. Adding capacity at one end exposes the next limit, so size both ends together.
Are these truck numbers realistic?
They are illustrative. The template is built to show how doors, staging and outbound doors interact, and the inputs, 4 trucks an hour and dwell times of 20 to 50 minutes, are starting points. Replace them with your own arrival rate and measured door times and rerun before drawing any conclusion about a real dock.